The Miller Family By Robert R. Phillips
The Miller family can be traced back several generations in Pennsylvania to a
Robert Miller who settled in the Little Sewickley Creek area around 1768 when
the western part of Pennsylvania was opened for settlement.
Robert Phillips and I visited recently (March 2009) and are in agreement
that we do have strong factual information that Robert Miller owned land on the
Big Sewickley Creek dated as early as 1773.
I have read somewhere that the headwaters of the Little Sewickley Creek
began near Hannastown. I have maps as
early as 1867 that show that the Little Sewickley Creek runs very close to just
SW of Greensburg, PA. This is about
7 miles SW of Hannastown “as the crow flies”.
If in case that is true, then I could align with that idea because known
factual information is that Robert Miller owned land in Hempfield township as
early as 1772 when taxes were collected in that County which was still Bedford
Co. at the time.
We just don’t know where that land was
exactly located. I personally
believe that land he owned was probably closer to Millers Station, Samuel
Miller’s home, about 2½ miles south of Hannastown.
There is little
information for this family before the raid at Hannastown in 1782, which is the
case for many of the families of this period.
Most of the supporting data for what I have written here has come from
William Boyd Duff's book "The
Forefathers and Families of Certain Settlers in Western Pennsylvania”
and searches on the Internet, and it
has allowed a history to be put together.
William Boyd Duff is a cousin of Robert Phillips and both of them can trace
their ancestry to Robert Miller through Robert’s son, Isaac.
Our side of the family’s ancestry is
related through Robert Miller’s son, Silas, Isaac’s younger brother.
Mr. Duff’s book, which includes many
other families than the Miller family, is well written and well researched.
Robert Miller is believed to have been born about
At the last minute Rev. Cuthbertson was told to stop in

While in
This line indicates that some of Mr. Phillips narrative was deleted
here for reasons of
brevity.
![]()
While
there appears to have been agreements
with the Indians, not all was peaceful as Indian raids continued. The family
information, (Family oral tradition perhaps
passed on down by Susanna Thomas Miller, Isaac’s widow who lived to be age
73.) states that Isaac Miller and a child from the Martin family
at Big Cove were taken in the Indian attack on 31 October
1755 on this settlement.
John Martin had settled in Big Cove before it was opened and
had established his family there.
By the time of the attack, Robert Miller and his wife also had other
children born to them at Big Cove.
The records go on to
describe that the two boys escaped after some time and went to Big Sewickley
Creek in
It is estimated that of the ninety-three settlers in Big Cove forty-seven were killed or captured. The ones that were captured were taken west to Ohio, but as noted above Isaac Miller and one of the Martin children were able to escape almost 7 years later. John Martin somehow discovered his children were being held in Ohio, and in 1762 petitioned the governor of Pennsylvania to help get them released (Pennsylvania Archives , Vol.4, page 100). While Isaac Miller does not appear in any of the records of this event, he is known by his descendants to have been involved. He also would not have been listed in any records of those released since he escaped. If Isaac was born in 1750, he would have been about four or five years old when taken by the Indians, and by 1762, he would have been about twelve. It may have been Isaac Miller and the Martin child that told John Martin where his other children were located. (Scroll to down to end to see a Miller time line.)
Sometime after 1755, Robert Miller, who was a farmer, moved his
family to the Hannastown area of
(See
the Patent Map Index for Robert Miller's property and surrounding property
owners.)
The “Hannastown
place” is harder to identify, but Robert Miller may first have moved to a
place south of Hannastown area in 1769 before settling on his three hundred
acres. The area was
known as Miller’s Station or Miller’s Blockhouse.
It was built by Samuel Miller who had settled near Hannastown by
at least 1772, but it could have been earlier.
This was the family home of Samuel Miller before he was killed.
It appears to have been expanded with cabins as sort of a local
meeting place and support center.
In the 1770s it was never called more than just “Miller’s Place”
where people had meetings.
The term “fort” was applied by an Army officer is his report, but there
was never a fort there. The
name Miller’s Station appears to have come from the fact that the
property is crossed by the railroad and became a local stop for trains,
but this was many years later.
People in the 1800s used that name in identifying the location.
An 1872 map showing the track of the Indian attack produced by
John B. Steel in 1895 locates “Miller’s Place” about two miles south of
Hannastown and about one mile east of the center of what is now
Greensburg. It now is on
the north side of the railroad.
(See this 1872 map and updated information on this page)On
this 1857 map it appears as owned by Mrs. Miller, but by 1872 the
property is owned by William Russell.
Robert Miller may have owned one of the cabins there.
(Scroll to down to end and
view Miller family timeline.
There is some thought that Samuel and Robert were brothers who
had a father named Isaac.
This is based on the common names of their
children and that their first sons were named Isaac.
William Boyd Duff also noted in his book that
Captain Samuel Miller came from the north of

This line indicates that some of Mr. Phillips narrative was deleted
here for reasons of
brevity.
![]()

Isaac Miller appears to have remained on the family farm and
helped his mother raise the other children until he took the Oath of
Fidelity before Hugh Martin on
A History of Butler County, PA. (1881) notes, that a Silas
Miller was “employed” for a time in protecting settlements against the
Indians in Westmoreland, Co.
Silas "removed" from Westmoreland to Middlesex
Township of Butler County in 1794.
It does
not appear that Isaac ever went east and engaged in the battles there.
He was part of the rear guard that protected
against the British led Indian attacks on the frontier.
However, the descendants of Silas indicate that
he did join the Continental Army in the east, which is supported by the
military records.
The marriage of Silas to Jane English in
Isaac Miller married his first wife about 1778 soon after the time he joined
the army. This is based on
information about first two children, Robert and Isaac, who were around 21 years
old when Isaac died in 1799 and who do not appear in any court records related
to the settlement of his estate.
There is nothing further known about his first wife; however, a search of the
families that lived near the Miller home near the Little Sewickley Creek might
give some clues.
Isaac married his second wife, Susannah Thomas, in 1783, which is based
on the ages of their children.
(Just the next year after the attack on Millers
Blockhouse in 1782.) When Isaac first married, he appears to
have established his homestead on the Big Sewickley to the west of Bell’s Mills
in Sewickley Township where the Indian village had been.
His brother, Silas probably located there
from New Jersey after the Revolutionary War and after his marriage to
Jane English. The Martin boy that
escaped with Isaac also established his homestead there but on the other side of
the creek in South Huntington Township.
By 1771 the Rugh family had built their blockhouse between Miller’s Place and
the
The attack on Miller’s Place also resulted in the death and capture of a number
of people, but there are no concise records.
This appears to have been an important affair since many of the notable
families attended. While there is
no record of Isaac and his family attending, it is very likely that they did.
Since Isaac Miller remarried about 1783, his first wife could have been
killed in the attack. Isaac and his
brother, Silas, were part of the militia that was to prevent these attacks;
however, the British led Indian attack was too sudden and powerful for these
settlers to stop. Isaac and his
brother also may not have been with their families due to their duties.
As suggested above, the second wife of Isaac, Susannah Thomas may have
had another husband named Robertson before she married Isaac.
Since there are no children of record, she may have just been married and
her husband also killed in the attack.
Whatever the case, Isaac had two sons when he married Susannah Thomas
sometime in 1783. It is estimated
that their first child, Amos Miller, was born in 1784.
While there are no papers related to the estates of the spouses,
perhaps because the county government at Hannastown was in disarray after the
attack in 1782 until after they were married.
There also may not have been any estates to be addressed.
The settlement of the estate of Robert Miller took over 17 years due to the
Revolutionary War and the Indian attacks.
The first part of the settlement occurred on
The background of Susannah Thomas Miller is very unclear except that according
to the family she was Welsh.
William Boyd Duff in his book lists what data there is.
He appears to prefer a William Thomas as her father, and he was the son
of George Thomas that resided in Hopewell Township of Cumberland County,
Isaac Miller appears to have spent most of his life as a farmer except for the
years in the army. He made his will
on
Isaac appears to have had some money at the time of his death since he requested
that other property be bought for his heirs.
However, this appears not to have occurred.
He also gave to his sons Emas/Amos and
William the 200 acres in the Donated Lands he was awarded for his military
service. William Boyd Duff in his
book discusses this property and the other property problems that the heirs of
Isaac had after his death. The
situation was similar to that of their father before his death.
Isaac Miller was buried in the graveyard of the Sewickley Presbyterian
Church, which also is known as the Associated Reformed Church of Sewickley, the
United Presbyterian Church and the Dick Church.
His grave there is marked as a veteran of the Revolution.
Susannah Thomas died on 10 January 1821 at the age of 73 years and is
buried next to her husband Isaac.
![]()
This line indicates that some of Mr. Phillips narrative was deleted
here for reasons of
brevity.
Miller Family Information
Miller - Big Cove Attack:
From William Boyd Duff's book, The
Forefathers and Families of Certain Settlers in Western Pennsylvania:
References to the Martin family are found in Boucher’s History of Westmoreland County (1906) vol. 1, p. 114 -115 and in: C.Hale Sipe’s, The Indian Wars of Pennsylvania, pgs.225-229. (1929). It is related that about one hundred Delawares and Shawnees from Ohio and Allegheny areas under the leadership of Shingas, the brother of King Beaver, on November 1, 1755 invading the Scotch-Irish settlements along the Great or Big Cove Creek.
Miller – Hannastown and Miller’s Place Indian attack (July 13, 1782) in found in:
C. Hale Sipe’s The Indian Wars of Pennsylvania, pgs.665-671. (1929)
George Dallas Albert's The History of the County of Westmoreland Pennsylvania, in footnotes on pgs. 149-150
“On 13 July 1782 Michael Rugh, his wife Phoebe, his 3 children, and his mother
Francina, were attending a celebration for a wedding that had taken place the
day before at a location known as “Miller’s Blockhouse”.
This was the home of the Samuel Miller
family. The entire wedding party was attacked by Indians. Several were killed,
possibly including Michael’s mother, Francina. Mrs. Miller was scalped and
managed to survive only to wear a skull cap for the rest of her life to hide her
lack of hair. On that same day another element of the same group of raiders
attacked and totally burned and destroyed the county seat of Hannastown.
Fifteen persons at “Millers” were taken prisoner the day of the attack. Michael
and his family were among the fifteen captives. They were taken to the Indian’s
camp near what is now “
"Westmoreland county, S. S. Before me, a Justice of the Peace in and for
said county of Westmoreland, personally appeared William Jack, Esq., who
was duly sworn according to law, did depose and say that Captain Samuel
Miller, who was killed by the Indians in the year 1778, at the
commencement of the Revolutionary War, actually settled on a plantation
now adjoining Peter Eichar, John Shoeffer, John Mechling, and others in
Hempfield township in the county aforesaid, that Andrew Cruikshanks (who
married the Widow of the said Captain Samuel Miller), Joseph Russell,
who is married to one of the Daughters of the said Samuel Miller, dec'd,
claims the benefit of an act of Assembly passed September 16, 1785, and
that the said Andrew Cruikshanks was in the course of the said war
actually in possession of the said plantation, and was drove away from
his habitation on said land by the Indians on the 13th day of July, A.
D. 1782, being the same day that Hannastown was burned and destroyed by
the Indians, and that, some of the heirs of the said Captain Samuel
Miller was killed and taken prisoners on the said day, and that the
House was burned and the property in the House by the Enemy, and that
afterwards the said Plantation lay waste and vacant for some time for
fear and dread of the Indians.
"WM. JACK.
Sworn and subscribed before me the ninth day of March, A.D. 1814. R.W. Williams (J.P.)”
(Justice of the Peace)
Est.
1725-1730........Robert
Miller born in Ayrshire, Scotland
Bef. 1750...............John
Martin located in Big Cove
1750.......................Rev.
Cuthbertson leaves Scotland with Rev Thomas Cameron
1750.......................Rev. Cuthbertson ministers in Ireland with
Rev Thomas Cameron
Est. 1750................Isaac
(son of Robert Miller) born in Ireland (Scotland?)
12 Jun 1751...........Rev.
Cuthbertson leaves Ireland for Pennsylvania probably from Londonderry
[Derry Loch]
5 Aug 1751............Rev.
Cuthbertson arrives in New Castle, DE (Pennsylvania) with colony of
Covenanters
1751......................Robert
Miller and family immigrated to New Jersey colony
Est. 1751...............Samuel
Miller also may have immigrated
1752......................Silas
(2nd son of Robert Miller) born in New Jersey in 1752
Abt. 1754...............Agreement
with Indians over the Big Cove area in Fulton Co.- earlier settlers were
told to leave.
Abt. 1754...............Robert
Miller and family settled at Big Cove, Fulton County, PA
31 Oct 1755...........Isaac Miller and John Martin's
wife and
children were taken captive by the Indians
by 1762................
Aug 13, 1762........John
Martin petitioned the Governor of Pennsylvania for the rescue of his
children
1768.....................Westmoreland
County area was purchased from the Indians [opened to settlement in
1769]
Est. 1769..............Miller’s
Place (Blockhouse/Station) built near Hannastown by Samuel Miller
1771.....................
by 1772................Robert
Miller had located in the Hannastown area - 300 acres on Big Sewickley
Creek?
3 Jul 1772............Pennsylvania
Archives, 3rd Series, Vol. 2, page 502 - Robert Miller caveat against
any other claims
on
Brownlee or John Campbell. The litigation continued to about 1797 or 1799.
Bef. 1773.............Robert
Miller, Samuel Miller and Gideon Miller are listed on the tax rolls of
in Hempfield Township,
Bedford County (at that time), PA
1773....................William
Brown assaulted Robert Miller - court case - probably over the property
16 May 1775........
1775.....................Robert
Miller died intestate - probably killed by Indians
11 Oct 1775.........Letters of Administration on the estate of Robert Miller, Huntington Township, yeoman, were "granted
to Agnes
Miller "widow and relict of the decedant" and Isaac Miller,
"eldest son".
1776...................
24 Sep 1777........
1777...................Isaac
Miller joined the Pennsylvania Regiment but remained in the area as rear
guard
Est. 1778............Isaac
Miller married first time [wife unknown, but they had two sons]
property on the Big Sewickley Creek for his home.
7Jul 1778............Capt.
Samuel Miller killed by Indians near Fort Hand while on Military duty.
[later his wife married
Andrew
1779 to 1792........Rents
were collected from the Sewickley property suggesting it was rented.
1 Feb 1780..........The
monies ("goods and chattel" only) of Robert Miller were distributed to
his heirs - He also owned 300 acres on a branch of Big
Sewickley Creek and property in Hannastown that was not distributed.
12 Jul 1782..........Wedding
at Miller’s Place
13 Jul 1782..........Miller’s
Place (Blockhouse) and wedding guests attacked by Indians
[15 people taken captive]
13 Jul 1782..........Hannastown
was burned by the same Indians
14 Jul 1782..........The
Duff home near Export was burned by the same Indians
Est. 1783..............Isaac
Miller married Susannah Thomas
1783.....................Captives
began to be returned and last army pay noted for Isaac Miller
1783-4..................People
left the Hannastown area in fear of further attacks [including part of
the Miller family]
30 Jan 1787..........Isaac
Miller, private in 8th Regt. PA in Deed Book 1, page 221.
For services granted 200 acres of
land in
1787.....................Several
of the children of Robert Miller are located in the western North
Carolina area.
1 Feb 1791............Robert
Miller’s heirs request his property be dispersed.
2 Nov 1791............Isaac
Miller and Michael Rugh post bond for the property of Robert Miller
13 Mar 1793...........Isaac
Miller reports the status of the property of
Robert Miller
1794......................Silas Miller (brother of Isaac) removed to Butler County, Pennsylvania, the next county just
northwest of
1799......................Isaac
Miller dies